The Monsters We Defy
Penelope, Leslye. The Monsters We Defy. New York, NY : Redhook, 2022.
Content Warnings: death, racism, references to slavery, violence.
I stumbled upon this book in a list of great magical realism novels and was thrilled to see that we had it at ACPL! Once I began reading it, I didn’t want to stop. What’s not to like with a setting of 1920s Black Broadway in Washington, D.C., characters talking to spirits Over There, and a little romance!
Clara Johnson made a deal with an Enigma years ago when she was imprisoned for killing a policeman in self-defense. The Empress, a strong spirit, gave her a Charm (a gift) that she refuses to use again, and a Trick, which compels her to aid anyone who asks her for help. She often communes with the spirit world to help people find answers to questions and solve problems. Unfortunately, that often means people are signing up for their own Charm and Trick, not realizing how much trouble they’re getting into.
Black DC residents are disappearing in droves. Before they disappear, they seem possessed, like a zombie. A mother comes to Clara with her afflicted son, but when Clara tries to connect with the spirit world, the Enigmas are silent. That has never happened before.
When she contacts The Empress, she tells her that the people are under the spell of a ring, and she needs to steal it. The problem is that the ring is owned by Josephine, an opera singer with bodyguards and too much fame to make it an easy heist.
She reluctantly joins up with Aristotle Bishop and brothers Israel and Jesse Lee, who have their own Enigma debts, and Zelda Coleman, an albino woman who was sold by her family to a circus when she was young. Can they figure out what the ring is doing to possess people, where the people go when they disappear, and how to break the ring’s spell?
This book has a bit of romance, but most of it is off page. I loved the historical elements. Clara works for Dr. Woodson at The Journal of Negro History, and works with Langston Hughes there. She attends an event at the Whitelaw Hotel, with the “Luminous 400.” The book also mentions the first Negro History Week. This would be a great read for Black History Month!
Mary Beth A. is the Community Engagement Librarian for Alamance County Public Libraries.






























